|
According to the Richmond, Indiana Wayne County Courthouse records John Ryan was born May 5, 1812 in the town (or townland or township) of Kelly, County of Kilkenney, Ireland. In spite of a careful search with the help of Irish professionals, we have not been able to locate John's exact birthplace. It seems there is no townland or township anywhere in the county with the name "Kelly" or a similar name. It is probable that the clerk who wrote "Kelly" on John's application for citizenship did not really hear what John recited (or felt it was not important to record it exactly.) Nonetheless, the county (Kilkenny) is recorded correctly and the county seat of that county is the city of Kilkenny.
CLICK HERE or on the thumbnail at left to view a full resolution map of Ireland showing where the city of Kilkenny is located. Numerous photos from our trip to Kilkenny are in my files and our visit there in the year 2000 was most enjoyable even though we did not locate John Ryan's birthplace. CLICK HERE or on the thumnail at left to see a typical scene from County Kilkenny. This photo was chosen from among many because it is a "scene" that John Ryan himself could have witnessed... and because it shows the lovely terrain of the county very well.
JOHN RYAN: U.S. CITIZENSHIP PROCESS
Of particular interest is the fact that John emigrated to America a full 15 years before "the famine" in Ireland. Also John emigrated as a bachelor at age 19 or 20. These circumstances (as well as his "stormy family life") make John unique among all our Irish ancestors. It would be interesting to know exactly what motivated John to emigrate... and how he wound up in Indiana; but research on these questions has been a "dead end" thus far.
John Ryan emmigrated to the United States in 1832. As can be seen in the court document (clickable just below) John asserts in court that he arrived in the U.S. June 5, 1832. [No passenger list searches have been undertaken thus far.] He applied for citizenship in the Wayne County Circuit Court September 6, 1836, but this is the first date on which we know his whereabouts with certainty! It is, in fact this document (Application for citizenship) from which we can calculate John's birthdate of May 5, 1812... and from which we also learn of his origin in County Kilkenny. A copy of this document was obtained and distributed by Uncle Charlie Greenen; but it has faded over time; and a newer hi-tech copy will be posted here when available. In the meantime you may CLICK HERE to see an abstract of the document.
It is not certain where he landed or how he spent his first 4 years in the U.S.; but it is assumed that he must have accrued skills and probably some savings. Later you will read that he reported himself as an "iron moulder" in the 1840 census... and was able to purchase a quite large home by 1844.
Furthermore, there is another interesting speculation regarding the events of August 1838.
Having applied for citizenship September 6, 1836, John actually received final citizenship status during the August 1838 term of the Wayne County Circuit Court. The court entry is begins on page 73 and runs over onto page 74 of that term... and can be seen by clicking on the two thumbnails at right. The Courthouse was located in Centerville at that time and was moved to Richmond much later. ![]()
PAGE 73
Click to enlarge![]()
PAGE 74
Click to enlargeThe court records do not indicate the exact date on which John Ryan was pronounced a citizen of the U.S. However, we know that he got married on August 21, 1838... and there is every reason to suspect that John (and Sarah) celebrated these two events as one gigantic "happening." It is quite possible that the citizenship ceremony and the marriage occurred on the same day.
Notice should also be taken here regarding the appearance of the name,Thomas O'Hara; as it was noticed that Thomas's citizenship declaration appears in the register immediately preceeding John Ryans. The name of Thomas and his wife, Elizabeth, appear so often and so strategically in this family's history; that it is speculated that the O'Haras were either very good friends (perhaps immigrant ship-mates) or even relatives of John Ryan. It is even speculated that Elizabeth O'Hara MIGHT have been a sister to John Ryan, who named his firstborn daughter Elizabeth... and one even wonders whether her real namesake might have been the Grandmother Ryan, who (as far as we know) never left Ireland.
Sarah Ann Moore was born about 1818 in North Carolina. Her parents were John & Sarah (Nelson) Moore. Very little has been discovered and almost nothing has been documented about her origins or her family of origin. The following is an outline of theories and the reasons behind the theories:
SARAH MOORE: ORIGINS 1. Sarah and her family might have been members of the "Quaker" religion. (Society of Friends.)
There are reasons to dispute this idea; but the following items seem to support it:
A. It is known that a large migration of Quakers occurred from North Carolina to Western Ohio & Eastern Indiana in the early 1800's. A fact which would "jive" with the family's known origin in North Carolina and their appearance in Indiana documents by 1838. B. Sarah never learned to read or write... a fact which is born out throughout her life by the "signing" of a myriad of documents with "her mark." (which was always an "X.") This would conform with the Quaker tradition of NOT educating girls at that time. [It also supports another theory: i.e. that Sarah might have been blind or deaf or handicapped in some other way.] C. The church registry entry for the baptism of her fourth child, Sarah, clearly indicates that "Sarah Anne Moore" is a non Catholic. The entry reads as above and also reveals why John Ryan and Sarah Moore were married by a Justice of the Peace... and why no record of a Catholic ("blessed") marriage can be located till the occasion of Sarah's "deathbed baptism."
"1848: On the same day (there was baptized Sarah, daughter of John Ryan and Sarah Anne Moore (non Catholic) who was born the 29th day of February. Sponsors were Thomas and Elizabeth O'Hara."
[Signed W. Engeln]D. "Moore" is a very common Quaker name. It is also known that there were other Moore families in Wayne County who were NOT Quakers. RESEARCH POSTPONED OR STALLED!
VOLUNTEER NEEDED!
THE MARRIAGE OF
JOHN RYAN & SARAH MOOREAdditional research has been done on John Kibbey, the Justice of the Peace who married John and Sarah. It turns out that he and his forebearers and descendants were widely known and respected. CLICK HERE to read more about John C. Kibbey and his family and reputation.
On August 21, 1838 John Ryan was married to Sarah Ann Moore in Richmond, Indiana, by Justice of the Peace John C. Kibbey. CLICK HERE or on the thumbnail at left to see the record of this marriage recorded in the Wayne County Marriage Register. At the time of their marriage, John would have been 26, and Sarah 19 or 20. As to the question of why an Irish Catholic would be married by a Justice of the Peace... and why there is no record of a church wedding, it has already been pointed out that Sarah Moore was definitely NOT Catholic; and my generation can remember how militantly the Catholic clergy attempted to avoid "mixed marriages." My elders (as well as historians) also assert that this "injunction" (both written and oral) was even harsher and more militant in the days of John Ryan. Furthermore, IF Sarah was indeed from a Quaker family, there would have been a double dose of negativity... with Sarah's family and pastor also unwilling to give their blessing to this marriage.
As you will read later, John and Sarah's relationship turned out to be the very sort of "conflicted and afflicted" marriage and family life that the clergy of the time would have predicted. And yet, the record will show that the family's Catholic pastors did not desert them... apparently being present and properly recording each and every event in the Family's life as it occurred... all the way down to Sarah's death and burial in 1905 from St. Mary's Catholic Church.
The following children were all born to John and Sarah in Richmond, Indiana between the years 1840 - 1856.
Click on the thumbnails at left to see the baptismal records. [Links not active! Poor quality registry copies sent to CDG to be replaced by actual certificates as soon as someone has time to expedite this!]
ELIZABETH A. RYAN b. 1840 MARY ELLEN RYAN b. 1841 JOHN ALBERT RYAN b. October 27, 1845 SARAH CATHERINE RYAN b. February 29, 1848 d. September 13, 1913 JULIA A. RYAN b. January 29, 1851 "presumed dead" by 1907 MARGARET MARTHA RYAN b. August 31, 1853 d. 1915 WILLIAM MARTIN RYAN b. March 31, 1856 d. 1910, Evansville, IN
THE 1840 U.S. CENSUS LISTING FOR THE
FAMILY OF JOHN RYAN & SARAH MOORE RYANThe 1840 Census listed only the head of household by name. All other information was given by means of tally marks within a series of columns. The summary for the household of John Ryan is as follows: The household is shown as containing one male and two females. The tally for John Ryan himself seems to be off by one column as it shows up in the column for age 20-30... whereas John was actually 32. The two females are tallied: one under 5 [which would correctly represent Elizabeth] and one between 20 and 30 [which would correctly represent Sarah Moore Ryan.]
Tally marks are also used to indicate "How many persons" are involved in various occupations. John Ryan's household shows one tally under "agriculture" and one under "industrial."
CLICK HERE to see a photo of the 1840 U.S. Census. [Link not active yet]
SARAH'S DEATHBED BAPTISM During the years between 1840 and 1850, not much information has been uncovered or passed down about this young family. We can assume that John was productive during those years, and we can also envision the kind of rural household they lived in until 1844 when they purchased a large home in downtown Richmond. The 1840 census indicates that they were involved in agriculture... and thus we can deduce that they probably lived outside of town and were doing some farming, with John doing his blacksmithing (iron moulding) in addition. There is no record of John ever owning land; but further research will be done in this regard. It is possible that John and Sarah were living on land owned by Sarah's family... or that they were "sharecropping."
Following the birth of the first two daughters, Elizabeth and Mary (1840 and 1841) no more children were born until after the purchase of the home in Richmond. Thereafter, children began to come at regular intervals; (see the chart above) and the baptismal registry at St. Mary's shows that each child was baptized as an infant according to the custom of the day.
Then suddenly on August 20, 1849, at age 31, more than a year after the birth of "little Sarah," Sarah Moore Ryan finds herself on death's doorstep from a cause (sickness? or injury?) which has remained a mystery. The names Thomas and Elizabeth O'Hara emerge again as being there for this family in a time of crisis... as does the (obviously Irish) name of the Catholic pastor, Fr. W. Doyle. Sarah obviously (from the record) gave her consent to be baptized; and the baptism administered by Fr. Doyle who also appointed himself sponsor... suggesting that there was serious urgency! Most likely the baptism was carried out with little preparation... and before John Ryan and Thomas O'Hara could be summoned from work.. Meanwhile, Elizabeth O'Hara stood as the other sponsor. These events, no doubt, occurred in the Ryan Home; but were recorded in the church registry as follows:
On the same day, Sarah also gave her consent for a Catholic "wedding." I suppose we would call it an "emergency deathbed wedding." As I envision the events, the "Nuptial Blessing" would have had to wait until the arrival of the groom; and thus, I can envision the priest pacing and waiting in Sarah's sick room, with his stole about his neck... and, perhaps some candles lit, until John Ryan and Tom O'Hara arrived from work. Tom was "volunteered" (probably no compromise) to be the "best man" ...and Mary Ryan (probably the 8 year old daughter of John and Sarah) stood as the other witness. The event was recorded in the church registry as follows:
Baptismal Registry Entry: August 1849:
"On the 20th of August I have baptized Sara Ann, wife of John Ryan, (maiden name Moore) in danger of death. Sponsors: W. Doyle and Elizabeth O'Hara. [Signed W. Doyle] "Sarah survived; and no document or tradition gives us a clue as to WHAT she survived... or how long the illness (or injury) lasted. As discussed above, however, events and documents from her later life suggest she may have been handicapped and could not read or write. We are only speculating as to whether these events of August 1849 might have been the cause of later problems... or whether she did indeed fully recover.
Marriage Registry: August 1849 On the 20th of August (I have given) the Nuptial Blessing to John Ryan and Sara Moore, after mutual consent of both parties, the woman having been baptized beforehand in sickness. Witnesses: Thomas O'Hara and Mary Ryan. [Signed W. Doyle] No doubt, Sarah's baptism and the "legitimizing" of her marriage to John relieved some "tension" within the family and their circle of friends. I did not, however, serve to "transform" their relationship; for, as we shall see, John and Sarah's relationship was a stormy one, and each harbored severe resentments and hostilities toward the other which will be expressed and documented a few years later in behaviors and divorce proceedings.
THE 1850 U.S. CENSUS LISTING FOR THE FAMILY OF JOHN RYAN & SARAH MOORE RYAN Name Age Relationship Occupation Birthplace Father's
BirthplaceMother's
BirthplaceJohn Ryan 38 . Iron Moulder Ireland Ireland Ireland Sarah 29 wife Housewife N. Carolina N. Carolina N. Carolina Elizabeth A. 10 . . Indiana Ireland N. Caroliina Mary E. 9 . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina John A. 4 . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina Sarah 2 . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina
DOMESTIC CHAOS EMERGES Two more children followed after the 1850 Census: Margaret Martha in 1851, and William Martin, in 1853. Other than baptism records, research has yielded no documents regarding the family's life between 1850 and 1860 as the young family grew up. We do know, however that John and Sarah's marriage was not a blissful one; and that John must have had some rather severe problems with alcohol, with his temper, and with "staying on task" as a provider for the family... as will be Sarah's complaint in a divorce suit in 1859. Many documents throughout this family's history attest to the fact that they had chronic and serious financial problems... and, in particular, there are repeated references to problems with the payment of the taxes on their house.
Tradition (by way of grandchildren, Mary and Catherine Greenen) indicates that the family lived much of their life in the country. Combining this tradition with known facts and documents, it would appear that the family probably maintained a house in the country as well as the large home in downtown Richmond. I speculate (and documents tend to corroborate) that John and Sarah began to take in renters (boarders) in their home to supplement their income. This arrangement also allowed John and Sarah to "live apart" when things got stormy. John's 1862 letters from the Civil War battlefield make reference to this arrangement.
On a positive note, if the children did spend considerable time living in town in the "big house" then it would have been a most pleasant setting. The house was large and spacious, and located just a block or two from St. Mary's church and downtown Richmond... and probably very close to their school. It was on a corner lot and also located on the main east - west (horse drawn) street car line. It was located in a "nice" neighborhood and the children would have constantly witnessed the high moral and "bustle" of Richmond, which was a growing and thriving industrial community at that time... and becoming a significant railroad center
In 1859, Sarah filed for divorce. The "grounds" listed in her complaint against John were abusing the children, alcohol abuse, and being a poor provider. The court records show that John answered this complaint to the satisfaction of the Judge; and the divorce was NOT granted. John's next move, however was a surprise!
THE 1860 U.S. CENSUS LISTING FOR THE FAMILY OF JOHN RYAN & SARAH MOORE RYAN
This census report contains a huge mystery and a big surprise as well. The studious reader will immediately notice that Sarah Moore Ryan is not listed. [Was the household temporarily without a mother? ...and, if so, why?] Also it appears that the Ryan household now includes a number of men who are probably boarders. It is believed that Mary (19) is not listed because she is already married. The table below lists the census entries with no attempt to embellish them or otherwise answer any questions.... but
WHERE IS THE MOTHER, SARAH MOORE RYAN?Name Age Relationship Occupation Value of
Real EstateBirthplace Father's
BirthplaceMother's
BirthplaceJohn Ryan 48 . Iron Moulder $2,000 Ireland Ireland Ireland Elizabeth 20 . . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina John A. 14 . . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina Sarah 12 . . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina Julia 8 . . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina William 4 . . . Indiana Ireland N. Carolina Alfred Cook . . Teamster . . . . Frank Patterson . . Pedlar . . . . Thomas Dudley . . Pedlar . . . . John Stearns . . Driver . . . . John Myers . . Pedlar . . . . By the time of this (1860) census, the Ryan family was complete... i.e. No more children followed after William, who was referred to even at age 6 (in one of John's letters from the battlefield, as "Little Billy." The mystery of where the mother of this family was will be answered later... in an 1865 document, well after the death of her husband, John Ryan. She was "living in Ohio" at the time! The question of exactly WHY she was in Ohio and not with her husband and children will probably be a perpetual mystery... except that other evidence seems to indicate that no house was big enough to contain the stormy and antagonistic relationship between John and Sarah by this time.
Indeed, it was not long after Sarah's suit for divorce was "disallowed" by the Judge, John recapitulated by suing Sarah for divorce. All that is left for us to "review" in this case is an 1879 receipt for the "taking of the records" of this complaint out of the court house. [These documents would have been the central focus of the 1879 proceedings which involved Sarah's claim for entitlement to a "widow's pension." Although it is understandable why the documents would have been sought (and removed) ...it is regrettable that they were never returned. I suspect they contained some unpleasant recitations and quite possibly there were parties involved who had good motives for them to "disappear."] We can only guess what John's complaints were, but the court docket indicates that the judge found in John's favor and granted the divorce!
JOHN RYAN JOINS THE UNION ARMY Although clerical errors are always possible explanations for things, it appears that John Ryan might have had to "confabulate" about his age in order to join the military. He did indeed join the Indiana 36th Volunteer Infantry Regiment Company F on September 1, 1861. His age is listed as 44 but court records shows that he was 49. He was 5 feet 11 inches tall, gray eyes and dark complexion. He mustered in October 23, 1861, at Richmond, Indiana, where the new regiment (36th Indiana Volunteer Infantry) was being formed.
We can only speculate regarding the motives John had for leaving a home with 5 children still at home and so many obviously unresolved family problems. On one hand it could be interpreted as "desertion" of fatherly duty. From another angle, there is plenty of evidence that John and Sarah had come to the realization that their relationship was too stormy to ever hope they could both live peacefully in one home. That is my assumption... and it is also my assumption that John would not have left for military duty unless he was sure that Sarah would return and provide constant care and supervision for the children.
Furthermore, there are other factors that are believed to have motivated John to join the military. In the first place was a "bounty" which was like a "bonus" which probably amounted to $300 to $500. (a large sum in those days!) Many documents show that the Ryan home was a very large one and that they had had problems meeting the taxes on the home for some time. The "bounty" would have eased this problem. There was also "relief money" involved which John mentions in his letters home. In addition, if John did have a drinking problem, and especially if he was perceived (as per the court document) as being an inadequate provider by his family and others, joining the military MIGHT have been seen by John as a means of demonstrating his adequacy, ...and, perhaps, as a structured means of handling an alcohol problem. Regardless of all this speculation as to why...
JOHN RYAN MARCHED OFF TO WAR AT AGE 49! We have created a separate document to record John's military history. This document can be found at:
http://www.wildirishroots.com/Greenen/RYAN/1812JohnRyan/1812JohnRyanMil/1812JohnRyanMil.html
For bravery at the battle of shiloh, he was promoted to corporal July 4, 1862.
CLICK HERE to see the 3 letters John wrote to his family from the battlefield during the Civil War:
http://www.wildirishroots.com/Greenen/RYAN/1812JohnRyan/1812JohnRyanMil/JohnRyanLetters.html
JOHN'S DEATH & SARAH'S "RECOVERY" It is plain from the letters John wrote home that he was not feeling well during the early months of 1862. It is clear from his letter (post Shiloh) that he was well enough to be in the fighting and that he demonstrated bravery. His condition, however, must have gradually worsened thereafter; as the record shows that he was admitted to General Hospital #3 at Louisville on October 14, 1862 and died of typhoid fever on November 25, 1862 in Louisville, Ky., He is buried there in Cave Hill Military Cemetery Section B Grave 1209.
Following John's death, a guardian, Lewis D. Stubbs, was appointed to look after the affairs and well-being of the Ryan children. The record is not clear; but it is assumed that Sarah had been living with the children and functioning as a family during the entire time that John was away doing military service... but we are not certain of this.
Upon the death of her husband, Sarah's most urgent agenda, was to "undo" the divorce that had been granted to John prior to his enlistment in the military. It would seem that this might have been more than a "face saving" endeavor, as the record of the divorce granted to John in 1860 (Case #656 -- part of which has been "removed" from the record) seems to have given John (and his heirs) ownership of the Ryan home and also might have prevented Sarah from receiving widow's pension and/or child support benefits. Regardless of her motives, Sarah filed a complicated motion on July 25, 1865 to have the divorce decree vacated, asserting that she held a life estate in the property and that it consequently belongs to the children named in the complaint. Among her arguments was the assertion that she was living in Ohio at the time John filed suit for divorce and that she was unaware the case was pending and, thus, did not respond to John's plea for divorce. The judge found in Sarah's favor and the divorce decree was vacated. Thus, on paper, (a very large stack of papers, in fact) John and Sarah were never divorced.
On August 20, 1879 Sarah (Moore) Ryan applied for a Civil War Widow's Pension of $8 per month until she died Feb. 24, 1905. Her children received $2 per month pension benefit until age 16 commencing July 25, 1866 till Jan. 28, 1867 for Julia, Aug. 30, 1869 for Margaret, and March 30, 1872 for William.
THE CHILDREN GROW UP There are continued hints in numerous documents that the Ryan children grew up in a troubled, fatherless, and sometimes chaotic environment. That "Little Billy" was a troubled child... and that there were long-standing religious and philosophical issues in the family is attested to by one of John's letters home from the battlefield. In the letter, he states he is glad "Little Billy" was finally baptized... and should be congratulated for "acting so good" in church... at age 5 or 6. As for why a Catholic baptism would be delayed till this age... that also appears to indicate serious family problems in this "mixed marriage."
By 1864 (and maybe sooner) both Sarah and Julia are attending school at St. John's in Indianapolis, a reputable Catholic boarding school for girls. Katie would have been 16, Julia, 12 or 13. The wonderful collection of receipts found in the Wayne County Courthouse by researcher Arnold Dean, clearly indicate payment of both tuition as well as rail transportation to and from Richmond to attend school. Note that the receipts indicate that the school was run by the "Sisters of Charity" ...but careful research by Andy Sauer have proven that the sisters running the school were the Sisters of Providence, headquartered in Terre Haute... and that this order of nuns (as well as several others) were referred to "generically" as the "Sisters of Charity" because of their work with the sick and wounded during the civil war; and are not to be confused with the "Sisters of Charity of St. Vincent DePaul." CLICK HERE to see a sample of a receipt for "Katie's" schooling in Indianapolis
SUMMARY OF CHILDREN
OF JOHN RYAN & SARAH MOORE RYAN
ELIZABETH A. RYAN Mason b. 1840
d. Unknown
Gravesite: [Cass County?]Elizabeth's married name was Mason. We have no information about her husband or family. In 1907 she was living in Cass County (Peru - Logansport area) with Ruby & "Alvie" Smith, (or vice versa) descendants of her sister, Julia. MARY ELLEN RYAN Rose Moore b. 1841
d. [before 1907]
Gravesite: unknownMary married ___Rose and then ___ Moore. Mary had offspring by both husbands, including a son, John A. Moore, some of whose history is known and is interesting. John A. married Emma Moore Moore, a niece of Judge Rupe (See Arnold Dean letters: ArnDn061800) JOHN ALBERT RYAN b. Oct 27, 1845
d. date & place unknown
Gravesite: unknownIn 1907, it was reported that John had "left town" and had not been heard from for many years SARAH CATHERINE RYAN Greenen b. February 29, 1848
d. September 3, 1913
Gravesite: Holy CrossOur ancestor! Her history is the impetus for this work. CLICK HERE to see the rest of her history! JULIA A. RYAN Krueger §§ b. January 29, 1851
d. Date & place unknown
Gravesite: unknownAttended St. John's as boarding student during high school following death of father. Married Carl Krueger of Cass County IN and begot one child, Ruby Krueger Smith. Julia "disappeared" before Ruby was raised. Was never heard from again but was assumed dead by 1907. Ruby married "Alvie" Smith and is known to have many descendants. Primary contact as of September 2001 is Julia's ggrandson, ALVIE SMITH of Rochester, IN MARGARET MARTHA RYAN b. August 31, 1853
d. 1915 - Indianapolis
Gravesite: Holy CrossNever married. Lived with her mother, Sarah Moore Ryan till Sarah's death. Spent time with family of her sister, Sarah, and tradition is that she was quite beloved. May have been handicapped in some way. WILLIAM MARTIN RYAN b. March 31, 1856
d. 1910, Evansville, IN
Gravesite: not knownWorked as miner. As of 1907, was working at "Big 4 Mine" near Linton, IN. Terse entry in Letter from his sister Sarah Ryan Greenen to her son, Tom, announced "your Uncle Billy's" death in 1910 and burial from Catholic church in Evansville.
§§ A marriage between a Julia Ryan and William Tyner is shown in the Wayne County court records; but no subsequent document ever confirms such a marriage for "our Julia" and thus it is felt that this is a different Julia Ryan.
SARAH'S LATER YEARS On August 20, 1879 Sarah (Moore) Ryan applied for a Civil War Widow's Pension of $8 per month which she which she received until her death in 1905. In all, Sarah would have spent 44 years as a widow; and records and traditions confirm that she spent the entire 44 years in the large home on 8th Street in Richmond... which, in prior and subsequent legal documents, came to be known as "The Ryan Property." [Note that about 1881 the layout of Richmond was changed and all the street names were re-designated. The original address of the Ryan property was 5th street; but the address became an 8th street address following the redesignation.]
It is not certain why Sarah waited till 1879 to apply for her widow's pension. Her divorce was vacated (invalidated) in 1865; but available records seem to indicate that she applied for her pension as well as the "child support" relief money she was entitled to in 1879... some 18 years after the payments should have started... and long after the date (1872) when her youngest child, Billy, would have outgrown his elibibility. It is possible that we are just mis-reading the documents; but it is also possible that Sarah was applying retro-actively. Regardless, she was successful; and the record shows that all the entitlements for widow's pension and child support were paid. This whole pension "business" contains another "mystery" and looms as another example of how difficult it has been to reconstruct this family's history.
Sarah's daughter, Margaret, never married and tradition is that she remained at home to care for her mother. In fact, it seems that sometime in 1902 Sarah executed a "deed" to the house selling her interest in the "Ryan home" to her daughter, Margaret for $1. It is unclear why she would have proceeded with such a transaction in light of the fact that her son-in-law, J.W. Greenen, had "rescued" the home for many years by payment of taxes, and actually held a deed to the home, having purchased it at auction from the county auditor at a "tax sale" in 1888. Perhaps Sarah's illiteracy (or ? a handicap) would account for such an apparent "defiance" of the facts... or perhaps the explanation is just that Sarah had "gotten her way" for 40 years in every transaction with guardians and judges... and expected to do so again.
Sarah died Feb. 24, 1905. Her funeral was at St. Mary's Catholic Church. She is buried in Earlham Cemetery Section 2 lot 77, Richmond, Indiana.
SARAH RYAN'S DEATH
AND ESTATE SETTLEMENTFollowing her death, a long and complicated lawsuit unfolded over the disposition of the Ryan home. In this lawsuit, J.W. Greenen (Sarah's son-in-law by reason of marriage to her daughter, Sarah,) who held a valid deed to the Ryan property, was the plaintiff and William A. Moore was the defendant. William A. Moore was the surviving spouse of Mary Ryan Rose Moore. From the titles of the documents, it appears that Mr. Moore was claiming entitlement to the Ryan home despite the fact that J.W. Greenen had payed the taxes on the home for some 30+ years and held the deed for the property, having purchased it at tax auction in 1888.
Professional researcher, Arnold Dean has managed to track down all the pertinent documents in this case as well as the summonses which were issued to all those entitled to shares of the estate's assets. Not only are they amazing to read in every aspect; but the list of those with entitlements allows us to learn of descendants of the Ryan family children still alive in 1907... and the summonses allow us to learn the whereabouts of each person who is entitled to a share. All of these documents from Mr. Dean are in my files and will be posted if there enough interest shown. In the meantime, Mr. Dean's letter summarizes things very well and you may CLICK HERE to see that letter.
Acknowledgement of assistance from professional genealogist Arnold L. Dean is hereby given:
126 SW 14th St.
Richmond, In 47374
(765) 935-0614
CLICK HERE to return to the Greenen Index Page.
CLICK HERE to view John Ryan's Military History